Turnabout Defective
- Author
- Najimi
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Length
- Short
- Approved
- Apr 5, 2026
- Views
- 139
- Favorites
- 1
Gumshoe was about to receive his hugest salary yet. And yet, fate had other plans…
Maintained by Fricka U, PinaDaPina, Knight, Wolfang, and Sheepish Started by Sp, Ordice, and Deadly Operated by mastyraJoin the Casing Hub on Discord
Gumshoe was about to receive his hugest salary yet. And yet, fate had other plans…
Hefaustas reviewed it 3/10
Oct 27Sheepish (Editor) reviewed it 3/10
Oct 25Caramelos reviewed it 4/10
Oct 23Added to the Vanilla Case List
Apr 5, 2026Log in with Discord to write a review.
A short case with a couple of fun ideas. I really like the initials on the letter matching both the defendant and the first witness. Unfortunately, past that, the case is riddled with problems: Key details of the case are never explained even after achieving truth, most of the contradictions are weak, the culprit is barely set up and their motive is poor, finally, pros has barely anything to work with.
All criticism aside, I hope the case-maker doesn't lose motivation and continues to hone their abilities and improve.
It's for sure a case and I will give the benefit that it is the casemaker's first ever case. However the fact that most people refuse to even acknowledge the clear issues presented in almost every single contra along with the weird flow of each testimony means the case is stuck in limbo. I yearn to see the next case...
Very obvious case that is overhyped (no offense to the casemaker) and ruined my expectations.