Frequently asked questions
Everything you need to know about how the case list works. Still stuck? Ask in the Vanilla Casing Hub on Discord.
Submitting a case
How can I get my case added?
Use the submission form.
What are the requirements for a case to be added?
It must be a fully functional, complete case. That means not a work in progress, and no known plot holes that can ruin the gameplay.
It should have a functional witness document that a witness can easily use, with appropriate notes. The path the case must take should be made clear to the witness.
Requests needed to reach the truth should be hinted at in a testimony or the court record, and should not be illogical. A request for something should already have been investigated, like prints or blood on a murder weapon.
Finally, make sure your plot is logical and can reasonably be figured out by a person.
How long after submission until my case is added?
The goal is to add new cases monthly at the start of each month, but schedules can shift.
Your case will be tested by an editor, either by joining a run or supervising one (this run cannot involve the CM).
You will then be contacted on Discord with the approval or denial. If denied, a valid reason will be given to help you improve the case.
What counts as a successful non-CM run?
If a run is completed fully to truth (or close enough to confirm playability) without the CM witnessing the case, it counts as a successful non-CM run.
As the CM you can spectate or play the Judge, as long as you do not backseat the run or influence the cast.
Non-CM runs are usually hosted by editors or helpers, who may take part or just supervise. You can run it yourself, as long as an editor is told and given details of how the run went.
Can I submit non-vanilla cases?
Yes. The case gets a Custom files tag, and its page has a Download custom files button linking to a Google Drive folder with the files needed.
How do I make a case?
Everyone has their own approach, but Fricka has written a guide with advice on making a case for VCL. Read the guide.
Cases on the list
How do I play a case?
Click a case to open its folder, then press Open document. If the case needs extra files, the Download custom files button is right next to it.
How do I sort and filter the list?
Use the search bar above the cases; ta works as short for Turnabout, so "ta feast" finds Turnabout Feast. On a phone, press Filters to see every option. You can order the list:
- Difficulty
- Length
- Highest rated
- Most viewed
- Newest
- Title, A to Z
- Title, Z to A
- Author, A to Z
Filters stack: for example, only Hard cases tagged Custom files. Hide NSFW removes NSFW cases and is remembered on your device.
What do the tags mean?
- Difficulty: the rough challenge for the defense: Easy, Medium or Hard.
- Length: average duration: Short (under 3 hours), Moderate (3 to 5 hours), Long (5 hours or more).
- New: added in the latest update.
- Tutorial: recommended for newcomers, in the Easy category.
- NSFW: explicit sexual or graphic content.
- Custom files: needs extra asset files, downloadable from the case page.
What makes a case NSFW?
A case depicting murder is far from enough (that is what Ace Attorney is built on). NSFW means more overt and gruesome depictions: gore images, or evidence with violent imagery that may unsettle some viewers.
It also covers nudity or sexual themes that are not appropriate for minors. A case can touch on these themes, and on sensitive topics like suicide, as long as it is not overly explicit.
Are the Google Drive links safe to download?
Yes. The editors made the Drive links themselves. If you need help swapping inis or setting up the files, the Resource Library has guides.
How often is the list updated?
The aim is an update on the first of every month at midnight UK time. The Docket on the home page shows the next planned update.
Why is a case missing?
Cases are reviewed for playability. If a case does not meet the requirements above, it has likely been removed or denied. For details on a specific case, contact frickau, kfcgull, or luwolfang on Discord.
I had an issue with a case. How do I report it?
Message frickau, kfcgull, or luwolfang on Discord.
How can I get a case removed from the list?
For any reason, contact frickau, kfcgull, or luwolfang on Discord.
How can I get a logo for my case?
Logos are made for every approved VCL case. To use the logo on your own case page, ask an editor for permission and credit them.
Logos generally are not made for cases that are not going on VCL, as they take time to make.
Logos are made by Wolfang (Discord: luwolfang), Fricka, Pina and Knight (Discord: kfcgull). Do not use them without permission.
Can I change the logo for my case?
If you do not like the logo or have a different idea, message an editor on Discord and they will try to fit the design to your needs. If you want to make your own, they can offer guidance (no guarantees).
Accounts, ratings and reviews
Why log in with Discord? What does the site keep?
Logging in lets you rate, review and favorite cases. The site only asks Discord for your username, display name and avatar; it never sees your email, servers or messages.
You can delete your account, with everything it posted, from My account at any time. The privacy policy has the full details.
How do ratings work?
Ratings come with reviews. When you write a review, pick a score from 1 to 10, or leave it at No rating; reviews without a score say "No rating provided". The rating counts once an editor approves the review. A case shows a score once it has 5 counted ratings.
Changing your review or your score sends it to the editors again; your published review and its rating stay up until the change is approved. Ratings given before this rule, without a review, do not count until you write a review for that case (your old score is filled in for you).
Reviewing a case marks it as Played in your case log. Cases marked Watched cannot be reviewed or rated, and moving a case away from Played removes your rating (your review stays).
To keep scores fair, ratings only count from accounts that are at least 24 hours old on this site and whose Discord account is at least 30 days old. Authors cannot review or rate their own cases.
Ratings also count by track record. A rating from someone with no other approved reviews counts 0.25 of a vote; it rises to a full vote once they have approved reviews of 4 other cases, and earlier ratings grow with it. Case averages use these weights, so a group of accounts that only rate one case cannot move it much, and a case needs ratings worth at least 2.5 full votes before it gets a score.
Top rated uses a weighted score, explained on the leaderboard, so a handful of perfect scores cannot jump past a case rated well by many people.
Who can post in the forum?
Anyone can read the forum. Posting opens once you have 5 published reviews: reviews are checked by editors, so this keeps the forum to people who already take part in the list, and keeps out spam and throwaway accounts. It counts reviews that are public right now, so a removed review counts against it. Editors and admins can always post, and only they start threads in Announcements.
Posts can use formatting tags (bold, headings, lists, spoilers, quotes and more; see Formatting help under the text box). Pasting a link to a case or a profile on its own line shows a card for it. A quote keeps the words as they were when you quoted them, even if the original post is edited later.
Images stay on the site you link them from; we do not store them. Images from common hosts (Imgur, Discord, Catbox, Gyazo, Tenor, Giphy) show straight away. Images from anywhere else show a button first, because loading them tells that site your IP address.
Posting in a thread follows it (or press Follow thread): you get one notification when someone replies, until you open your notifications. Writing @username in a post tells that person (mentions inside quotes do not). Threads and posts you have not seen are marked New, and Mark all read clears them. You can like other people's posts, and search the forum from its front page.
Use Report under a post if something breaks the rules; editors can remove posts, lock or move threads, and see earlier versions of edited posts.
Why is my review not showing?
Every review is checked by an editor before it appears. If it is not approved, you will see the reason on the case page and can edit it and send it again. Editing an approved review sends it back for checking.
To keep the queue manageable, each account can send 10 reviews a day (edits and resends count). Trusted reviewers and editors have no daily limit.
How do I mark a review as having spoilers?
Tick This review contains spoilers before sending it. Readers then see a "Contains spoilers" bar and open the review only if they want to. Editors can also add or remove the mark when they approve it.
What do Helpful and Funny do?
Under each review, press Helpful (thumbs up) or Funny (smiley), or both. Press again to take it back. The review shows how many people found it helpful or funny, but not who. You cannot vote on your own review.
How do I add a signature to my reviews?
Upload a wide banner in My account: a 6:1 shape, ideally 1200 x 200 (at least 600 x 100), as PNG, JPEG, WebP or GIF up to 2 MB. Animated images work. An editor checks it first; once approved it shows under your reviews and on your profile, and replaces your previous one.
I made a case on the list. Can I post updates on its page?
Yes. If editors have linked your account as an author of the case, an Author's notes box appears on its page. Post short dated notes there, such as fixes or new versions. People following the case or you are told.
Why are some names colored, and what are the tags next to them?
Names in red belong to admins and names in blue to editors, the people who run the list; their profile pages also carry an Admin or Editor tag. The tags next to names are titles the admins give out, such as Casemaker, Trusted or Curator. If you have more than one, choose which shows (or none) in My account.
What is My case log?
On any case page, the My case log menu marks the case as Played, Want to play or Watched. Your profile counts how many of the listed cases you have played and shows your lists. Choose None to clear it. These marks show on your profile's activity, not in the Recent activity on the home page.
What does the bell do?
The bell next to your account menu tells you when an editor approves, does not approve, or removes one of your reviews (with the reason), when an admin changes your display name, titles or role, and when an editor removes your tier list. Staff are not named.
Press Follow on a case page to also hear when a new review of that case is approved and when its author posts a note. Press Follow on someone's profile to hear when a review of theirs is published or they post an author's note. See or stop your follows in My account.
Opening the bell marks everything as read. See all notifications shows older ones; read notifications are cleared after 90 days.
How do I make a tier list?
Open My tier list from your account menu. Drag case logos into tiers, or tap a logo and pick a tier from the bar that appears. Rename, recolor, add or remove tiers as you like; changes save on their own.
Your list shows on your profile under Reviews, and has its own page you can link to. Each account has one list, and you can update it whenever you want.
Can I hide from the Online now list?
Yes. Untick Show my name in the Online now list in My account. You are then counted as a visitor instead of being named.
Have a different question? Reach frickau, kfcgull, or luwolfang on Discord, or ask in the Vanilla Casing Hub.